[home][rumors and news][model release matrix][dealer network][desktop calendar][exhaust notes][tov forums][links][search][sponsors][garage][login]

Tire Rack Upgrade Garage
 Search for a Dealer:
 Canadian Flag US Flag
 Honda Acura
 ZIP  
2016 ILX and 2015 HR-V to debut at 2014 Los Angeles Auto Show
More.......................
New Acura and Honda Products Fuel Surge in September Automobile Sales
More.......................
2015 CR-V goes on sale tomorrow. Full details released.
More.......................
All-new Honda Civic Type R: unrivalled against the brand's iconic performance flagship models
More.......................
Honda reveals 2015 CR-V
More.......................
Honda adds Special Edition trim level to 2015 Civic Lineup
More.......................
Honda releases sales figures for August 2014
More.......................
2015 Accord goes on sale today, "Gets Multiple Feature Upgrades"
More.......................
NSX --> Re: NSX new info!!! NSXPO 2014
Join Discussion......
TLX --> Re: Driving 2015 SH-AWD TLX this week
Join Discussion......
TLX --> Re: "Game-Changing TLX"
Join Discussion......
Today's Reading Links --> Re: Tesla P85D: AWD, 0-60 in 3.2 seconds
Join Discussion......
CR-V --> Honda Carplay
Join Discussion......
General Talk --> Re: What does having a VIN # mean?
Join Discussion......
General Talk --> Re: Acura 2016 and Beyond...
Join Discussion......
General Talk --> Re: Diesels bad?
Join Discussion......
TLX --> TLX Launch Package
Join Discussion......
CR-V --> Re: Saw a 2015 CR-V today
Join Discussion......
Professional Motorsports --> Re: F1 Honda PU hints
Join Discussion......
General Talk --> Re: The Pursuit of Arete
Join Discussion......
Accord --> Re: Hope everything works out. Very nervous.
Join Discussion......
ILX --> Re: 2016 ILX
Join Discussion......
Civic --> Re: Will the 2016 Civic be bigger?
Join Discussion......
TOV First Drive: 2015 Acura TLX
Read Article....................
Photo Gallery: 2015 Acura TLX 2.4 P-AWS
Read Article....................
Photo Gallery: 2015 Acura TLX 3.5L SH-AWD
Read Article....................
TOV Photo Gallery: 2015 Honda Fit
Read Article....................
PR Photo Gallery: 2015 Honda Fit
Read Article....................
TOV Dyno Test: 2014 Accord Hybrid
Read Article....................

[fancy] [flat] [simple]
TOV Forums > Today's Reading Links > > Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers

Go to:

Viewing Threshold (What is this?)

Thread Page - [1]
Author
  Post New Thread
A.W.E.S.O.M. - O
Profile for A.W.E.S.O.M. - O
"Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 13:45
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
A great article in the USA Today on how "dealer invoice" is a misguided number to lull consumers into thinking they're getting a great deal. Really an interesting read.

An excerpt:

FIGURING WHAT DEALERS REALLY PAY FOR A CAR:
The dealer's actual cost for a car -- which will determine a price you can negotiate -- may be much lower than the so-called invoice price because of undisclosed rebates from the maker. This example uses actual sticker, invoice and holdback amounts, but then subtracts hypothetical rebates of the sort often given to dealers, showing how the true cost to dealers might be much less than the invoice price that's the popular benchmark for car shoppers.

Sticker price — $19,655
Invoice price — $18,869
3% holdback — $590
Bonus for meeting sales goal — $200
Good customer feedback bonus — $300
Bonus for selling this model — $100

Dealer cost — $17,679


More here:
http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2012/12/06/car-shopping-prices-roundtable/1749101/
NealX
Profile for NealX
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 14:08
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
Interesting. Are these "numbers" for a particular model or brand?
A77
Profile for A77
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 14:21
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
I don't know about the states - but dealer holdback is 1-2% here. Its stated purpose is to help cover interest costs on unsold inventory - obviously the longer a car is in stock the lower the holdback fee profit. Some manufacturers do not provide holdback apparently. There are no sales goal bonuses from honda, no good customer feedback bonuses (but BMW have them for sure here) and no undisclosed model bonuses. It's a very different story for domestics though. There is however "profit" in the freight and PDI in as far as not the full quoted cost is paid to Honda. A proportion, about 25% is held by the dealer. But is used to pay for PDI costs, filling the car with gas, etc. So not pure profit, but some.

There's far more profit in dealer doc fees (almost 100%), and all the business office fluff.
siegen
Profile for siegen
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 14:25
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
I read somewhere a while back that Honda has 2% dealer hold-back (off base MSRP). Wish I still had the source. I researched this a while back when looking for my new car.

Haven't heard about those other incentives but it wouldn't surprise me.

I'm sure they make a profit on the other fees that are charged, such as preparing the documentation and licensing. And they'll usually try to add dealer prep and other fees on top of the purchase price.
A.W.E.S.O.M. - O
Profile for A.W.E.S.O.M. - O
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 14:27
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
Neal wrote:
Interesting. Are these "numbers" for a particular model or brand?


They are an 'example'.

The gist of the article (a roundtable of industry experts on car pricing who were interviewed at the LA Auto Show) is that in an industry as big as autos, there's no way the key players would let 'true cost' be known to buyers - just way too much to lose.

I believe that mention in the article that in the '90s, dealer cost was 80-85% of MSRP. They say now it's closer to 95% of MSRP - an indication the manufacturers and dealers are hiding true "dealer cost".
JDMImport
Profile for JDMImport
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 15:08
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
I think your heading is a little over the top. A dealer does not have to show you the invoice hence why it does not exist to fool customers. Dealers do pay what the invoice amount is, and holdback is paid back after the sale.

Not all manufacturers pay bonus incentives for volume or good customer satisfaction. The only constant is holdback, which is intended to pay off lot charges when most dealers have their cars owned by a bank.

I have never understood the desire to rat out dealers and have them sell a car for less than they paid for it. No other business is like that. Bottom line is if you don't like the deal you are getting, don't buy the car. There will ALWAYS be someone who pays less than you and someone who pays more.
Dren
Profile for Dren
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 15:29
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
JDMImport wrote:
I think your heading is a little over the top. A dealer does not have to show you the invoice hence why it does not exist to fool customers. Dealers do pay what the invoice amount is, and holdback is paid back after the sale.

Not all manufacturers pay bonus incentives for volume or good customer satisfaction. The only constant is holdback, which is intended to pay off lot charges when most dealers have their cars owned by a bank.

I have never understood the desire to rat out dealers and have them sell a car for less than they paid for it. No other business is like that. Bottom line is if you don't like the deal you are getting, don't buy the car. There will ALWAYS be someone who pays less than you and someone who pays more.



You beat me to it. Dealers aren't trying to steal your money, but they certainly want the best deal for them; and you want the best deal for yourself. This is no different than anything else you purchase. McDonalds has a much higher profit margin.
RHalabi
Profile for RHalabi
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 15:49
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
obviously! When those people brag at below invoice they are kidding themselves if they think the dealer paid that. Nobody runs a business to break even or lose. Never did, never will. Except when impending bankruptcy is soon.
NealX
Profile for NealX
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 16:04
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
Dren wrote:
JDMImport wrote:
I think your heading is a little over the top. A dealer does not have to show you the invoice hence why it does not exist to fool customers. Dealers do pay what the invoice amount is, and holdback is paid back after the sale.

Not all manufacturers pay bonus incentives for volume or good customer satisfaction. The only constant is holdback, which is intended to pay off lot charges when most dealers have their cars owned by a bank.

I have never understood the desire to rat out dealers and have them sell a car for less than they paid for it. No other business is like that. Bottom line is if you don't like the deal you are getting, don't buy the car. There will ALWAYS be someone who pays less than you and someone who pays more.



You beat me to it. Dealers aren't trying to steal your money, but they certainly want the best deal for them; and you want the best deal for yourself. This is no different than anything else you purchase. McDonalds has a much higher profit margin.


I'll try and remember that next time I buy a $25,000 Big Mac®!
;-)
MasterOfDaDomain
Profile for MasterOfDaDomain
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 16:56
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
Best price means the best one can get from local dealers - it may be below invoice or near MSRP - it all depends on supply and demand.
A.W.E.S.O.M. - O
Profile for A.W.E.S.O.M. - O
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 18:58
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
Dren wrote:
JDMImport wrote:
I think your heading is a little over the top. A dealer does not have to show you the invoice hence why it does not exist to fool customers. Dealers do pay what the invoice amount is, and holdback is paid back after the sale.

Not all manufacturers pay bonus incentives for volume or good customer satisfaction. The only constant is holdback, which is intended to pay off lot charges when most dealers have their cars owned by a bank.

I have never understood the desire to rat out dealers and have them sell a car for less than they paid for it. No other business is like that. Bottom line is if you don't like the deal you are getting, don't buy the car. There will ALWAYS be someone who pays less than you and someone who pays more.



You beat me to it. Dealers aren't trying to steal your money, but they certainly want the best deal for them; and you want the best deal for yourself. This is no different than anything else you purchase. McDonalds has a much higher profit margin.



I provided the story today because many come on TOV and boast of what they paid compared to "invoice". If you read the article, it states that those customers are "least satisfied" with their purchase and that a good percentage focus on the total experience and don't drive deals "to the bone". I'm in that group ... people need to be paid.

The McDonald's comparo doesn't work though. Making 30% margin on a $3 item is a long way from making 10% on a $30,000 one. McDonald's needs to sell a 1,000 burgers for every one car deal at $30,000.
superchg2
Profile for superchg2
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-07-2012 20:00
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
There really is nothing wrong with a Dealer making a fair profit on a new car and what a dealers pays for these cars is fairly transparent.

Used cars actually are where higher profit potential exists for a dealer. Since the buyer of a used car has no idea what a dealer paid for a trade-in or car purchased at auction, it is pretty hard to know what they are making.

Some times a used car manager will make a low bid on a trade-in, especially if they already know that the new car is being discounted heavily. When this used car is subsequently sold on the lot, the potential profit can be several thousands of dollars for the dealer.

This is also why the used car and service departments are critical to most dealer's making a profit.



Dren
Profile for Dren
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-09-2012 10:35
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
A.W.E.S.O.M. - O wrote:
Dren wrote:
JDMImport wrote:
I think your heading is a little over the top. A dealer does not have to show you the invoice hence why it does not exist to fool customers. Dealers do pay what the invoice amount is, and holdback is paid back after the sale.

Not all manufacturers pay bonus incentives for volume or good customer satisfaction. The only constant is holdback, which is intended to pay off lot charges when most dealers have their cars owned by a bank.

I have never understood the desire to rat out dealers and have them sell a car for less than they paid for it. No other business is like that. Bottom line is if you don't like the deal you are getting, don't buy the car. There will ALWAYS be someone who pays less than you and someone who pays more.



You beat me to it. Dealers aren't trying to steal your money, but they certainly want the best deal for them; and you want the best deal for yourself. This is no different than anything else you purchase. McDonalds has a much higher profit margin.



I provided the story today because many come on TOV and boast of what they paid compared to "invoice". If you read the article, it states that those customers are "least satisfied" with their purchase and that a good percentage focus on the total experience and don't drive deals "to the bone". I'm in that group ... people need to be paid.

The McDonald's comparo doesn't work though. Making 30% margin on a $3 item is a long way from making 10% on a $30,000 one. McDonald's needs to sell a 1,000 burgers for every one car deal at $30,000.



Profit margin is profit margin. Mcdonalds does sell 23948723987493274 burgers, I don't think car dealerships do that... But to the point of your article, it is why the real big dealerships sell at invoice a lot of times. They sell in such volume that they make a lot of their "profit" on the kick backs from the manufacturer.

But when it comes down to it, buying a car is mutual benefit. Both parties are happy and a deal is done, if not, a deal will not be reached.
Dren
Profile for Dren
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-09-2012 10:38
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
superchg2 wrote:
There really is nothing wrong with a Dealer making a fair profit on a new car and what a dealers pays for these cars is fairly transparent.

Used cars actually are where higher profit potential exists for a dealer. Since the buyer of a used car has no idea what a dealer paid for a trade-in or car purchased at auction, it is pretty hard to know what they are making.

Some times a used car manager will make a low bid on a trade-in, especially if they already know that the new car is being discounted heavily. When this used car is subsequently sold on the lot, the potential profit can be several thousands of dollars for the dealer.

This is also why the used car and service departments are critical to most dealer's making a profit.






That's why I like dealing with dealerships when purchasing a used vehicle, especially say a Honda from a Ford dealership, or vice versa. You can really low ball because they likely bought the car very cheap.
TonyEX
Profile for TonyEX
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-09-2012 13:53
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
Dren wrote:
superchg2 wrote:
There really is nothing wrong with a Dealer making a fair profit on a new car and what a dealers pays for these cars is fairly transparent.

Used cars actually are where higher profit potential exists for a dealer. Since the buyer of a used car has no idea what a dealer paid for a trade-in or car purchased at auction, it is pretty hard to know what they are making.

Some times a used car manager will make a low bid on a trade-in, especially if they already know that the new car is being discounted heavily. When this used car is subsequently sold on the lot, the potential profit can be several thousands of dollars for the dealer.

This is also why the used car and service departments are critical to most dealer's making a profit.






That's why I like dealing with dealerships when purchasing a used vehicle, especially say a Honda from a Ford dealership, or vice versa. You can really low ball because they likely bought the car very cheap.



We often sell our used cars to the used car manager.

The price is always wholesale.
TonyEX
Profile for TonyEX
Re: "Dealer Invoice" a fallacy to fool consumers    (Score: 1, Normal) 12-09-2012 14:01
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
Neal wrote:
Interesting. Are these "numbers" for a particular model or brand?


The holdback is standard. The last time I looked, AHM has a 2%. In the rear occasions we have bought a 'new' car, from the factory, we get the holdback check a couple of weeks later.

I think the other numbers are not so secret. I have seen them published in web sites. I mean, you can bet that no dealer is going to be selling a car with a $2000 rebate unless the factory is providing the rebate.
 
Thread Page - [1]
Go to:
Contact TOV | Submit Your Article | Submit Your Link | Advertise | TOV Shop | Events | Our Sponsors | TOV Archives
Copyright © 2014 Velocitech Inc. All information contained herein remains the property of Velocitech Inc.
The Temple of VTEC is not affiliated with American Honda Motor Co., Inc. TOV Policies and Guidelines - Credits - Privacy Policy
mobile: 0